Understanding the Association Attorney: A Guide for HOA Boards

By Daniel Brannigan
Image Description

Community association board members are volunteers with serious responsibility and potential liability. Knowing when and how to rely on an attorney who understands association law is one of the best protections a board has.

Why does an association need its own attorney?

Board members have a fiduciary duty — one that cannot be delegated — to properly manage the association’s activities and property. Boards should be able to focus on governance decisions, such as budgeting, capital planning, and rules while deferring to experts in their own field.

One call to an attorney could save time, stress, and money. Among other situations, associations should call counsel to:

  • Draft, record, and amend any document that impacts the title to a parcel of land
  • Review proposed resolutions and rules before they’re implemented
  • Review all collection policies and procedures to ensure state and federal fair debt collection requirements are being met
  • File liens, garnishments, releases, and other court documents
  • Review insurance policies before they’re purchased and claims before they’re filed
  • Represent the association during a court appearance, lawsuit, state complaint, code violation, or board recall petition
  • Review all contracts, such as business partner agreements, before the association signs
  • Review all personnel policies and manuals to ensure they comply with federal and local labor laws
  • Advise the board before any purchase or sale of association property
  • Review proposed community remodeling projects, which could be material alterations of common elements and areas 

How does an association best use its counsel?

The association should have a written engagement agreement that spells out the scope of the representation and the terms of billing and payment.

The scope of engagement should be broad enough to allow counsel to become familiar with all activities of the association. That is better than having counsel do specific tasks. Assigning only some law-related tasks to counsel might lead to conflicting advice or keep counsel from giving full advice. 

The board should designate one person to interact with its attorney. This not only controls costs but eliminates confusion and miscommunication. In addition, if the community has one, the association manager needs to work very closely with the attorney. The two professionals should have a positive and productive working relationship.

The association’s attorney is legal counsel to the association and neither represents the board, any single member of the board, or any particular officer or homeowner.

How should you select an attorney?

Next to selecting a community association manager, the most important decision a board can make is selecting its attorney.

Associations would be wise to choose an attorney with expertise in community association law.

It is almost never advisable to hire a member of the association to be the association attorney, whether compensated or on a volunteer basis.

CAI has recognized excellence in the practice of community association law through the College of Community Association Lawyers. CCAL fellows distinguish themselves by advancing community association law for the betterment of the communities they serve. 

>>Read more about the value of CCAL fellows.

>>Get more detailed guidance about hiring an association attorney in CAI’s guide for finding the right professional.

Roger Minch, a resident of The Towers condominium in Fargo, N.D., and of counsel for Serkland Law, contributed to this article.

Get More Expert Advice

Join CAI’s online community for access to the industry’s most in-demand community association resources.

Thousands of your peers are sharing advice.

Daniel Brannigan

Daniel Brannigan is CAI's senior director of publishing.